By Donald H. Harrison
LONG BEACH, Calif.— Some of you have seen the slogan on the homepage of jewishsightseeing.com,
that "there's a Jewish story everywhere." Of course, I'll never be
able to completely confirm this hypothesis, because I can't physically visit everywhere.
But after spending a day here in Long Beach, I couldn't help but feel even
more confident that the saying is true.
I am not talking about seeing Jewish things in Long
Beach. That would be too easy. Many people know that the Queen
Mary, today anchored as a museum and hotel in the bay of
Long Beach, once boasted a kosher kitchen and its own synagogue. One can simply Google
the combination "synagogues, Long Beach, California" to be led to
the websites of Temple
Israel, Temple Beth Shalom and Mikveh Yisroel-Lubavitch, each a place where
Jewish stories continue.
Prof. Arlene Lazarowitz, director of the Jewish Studies program at California
State University at Long Beach, hosted on Sunday and this morning the 12th
Annual Western Jewish Studies Association Conference, bringing together faculty,
students and independent scholars to discuss a variety of Jewish topics. I
was there to tell the story about San Diego's first Jewish settler, Louis
Rose, on a panel titled "Jewish Communities in the West," and, to
tell the truth, I couldn't wait to stop talking in order to hear the other
panelists who had tales to tell about Jewish pioneers in places like Montana,
New Mexico, and Oregon.
Arianna Margolin, a student at the University of Montana, traced the life of
Joseph Soss, a German-born Jewish entrepreneur, who built the state Capitol
building in Helena,
Montana. One of Soss' Jewish chums was Henry Frank, an early mayor of Butte,
and another was businessman Ben Hager, who supplied building materials from his
quarry. The Capitol was dedicated on July 4, 1902.
Prof. Noel Pugach of the University of New Mexico outlined the lives of the
Herzstein and Moise families of eastern New Mexico. Morris Herzstein was a
merchant in Liberty,
New Mexico, so named because the town was the only place within a short distance
of an Army fort where soldiers could go off duty. They visited a brothel,
a saloon, and Herzstein's general store. But unfortunately, soldiers were
not his only visitors: the train robber, Tom "Black Jack"
Ketchum, and his gang came by, scooping up the cash in the process. When
Morris' brother, Levi, gave chase—apparently not knowing who they were—it
was Levi's last ride. His body was found riddled with bullets. Another
family member, Simon Herzstein, was elected to the school board in Clayton,
New Mexico—which, Pugach informed us, is the smallest town in the United
States to have its own Rotary Club.
In Santa Rosa,
N.M., there is a Moise Memorial Library. Sigmund and Julius Moise both
were mayors of the town. The family started as merchants, later became bankers,
and then, just naturally, became ranchers because their customers often would
pay them in land and cattle. Morris Moise chaired the Union County
Democratic Party.
Prof. Jack Sanders of the University of Oregon told of Samuel
Rothchild, an original member of the City Council of Pendleton,
Oregon. As this Rothchild traveled to the United States in steerage, it's
unlikely he bore any relation to the famous banking family of Europe, who
spelled their names with an "s" in the middle—Rothschild.
But sans-S Rothchild wasn't anyone's economic fool. He paid something
less than $2,500 for 640 acres of land, and sold the same parcel for over
$9,000. He was involved in the local publishing company, invented an
improved harrow, served as the worshipful master of the local Masonic Lodge,
and, in 1880, drafted the articles of incorporation for the City of
Pendleton. In the election that followed, only one of the 188 voters
in town refused to vote for him. That was Rothchild himself, out of a
sense of modesty.
Another panel at the WJSA Conference further buttressed the "Jewish story
everywhere" thesis. Titled "Hostile Times/ Jewish
Responses," it featured Profs. Victoria Khiterer of the University of
Central Arkansas; Holli Levitsky of Loyola Marymount University, Matthew
Washawsky of the University of Portland, and Leila Kiknadze, of Tbilisi
State University in the Republic of Georgia.
Khiterer, a Russian, described the tussle in the early 1900s between the Czar's
government and U.S. President Theodore
Roosevelt over Russian refusal to honor the terms of an 1832 commercial
treaty, in which each country had agreed to honor the passports of the other's
citizens. When Americans filled out Russian visa applications, they were asked
their religions. Those who answered "Jewish" were denied a visa.
In Khiterer's view, although the Czar Nicholas II was anti-Semitic, he still
wanted Jews to live in his empire because they helped to spur economic
growth. In the czar's palace in St.
Petersburg, there was concern that the Jews might be lured away—especially
by other Jews who were members of their families, or former residents of their
towns, and who had made financial successes in America. Frustrated,
Roosevelt eventually canceled the commercial treaty in protest.
Kiknadze, from the neighboring nation of Georgia,
said Jews were well established in her country for centuries before the advent
of Christianity. The tradition of the Jews of Georgia is that they are
descended from the "Ten Lost Tribes" of Israel, the Northern
Kingdom in the Bible. Another tradition is that they migrated to Georgia
during the time of the Babylonian exile, around 587 BCE. Jews were well
entrenched in Georgia some two and a half centuries later when the land was
conquered by Alexander the Great.
A tradition holds that a Georgian Jew, Elioz, traveled to Jerusalem in time to
witness the crucifixion of Jesus. A convert to Christianity, Elioz is
credited with transporting the robe of Jesus to Mtskheta,
Georgia, where a cathedral stands over the robe's burial place. A Jewish
tombstone dating to the 2nd century CE provides physical evidence of the
longtime Jewish presence, according to Kiknadze.
Levitsky related the story of Sarah Nomberg-Przytyk, a Polish communist
functionary from Lublin, who
survived Auschwitz but simply could not adjust to the dismemberment of the
communist system in Eastern Europe. She ended up moving to her son's hemp farm
in the Canadian province of Quebec, and later onto Israel, where she died.
Washawsky described the tribulations of Tomás Treviño de
Sbremonte, who was burned at the stake in Mexico
City by civilian authorities after being found guilty of "Judaizing"
by the Inquisition. Refusing to repent, Treviño was burned at the stake
without first being put to death by garroting. Washawsky said more than 500
pages about Treviño were compiled by the Inquisition. The scholar noted
that in the records, Judaism never was referred to as "Judaism," but
rather as the "Law of Moses." Interestingly, Treviño did not
lead a life committed to the practice of Judaism, he wavered back and forth
between the crypto-Judaism of his mother, and the Christianity of his
father.
Treviño was a wealthy merchant, who made much of his fortune in the sea trade
between Acapulco, Mexico,
and Manila, the
Philippines—two more venues where there are Jewish stories..
|