By Donald H. Harrison
SAN DIEGO—After watching Inside Man with her father, Sam
Zeiden, at our home, Nancy
put the DVD in its container on my desk. "You might want to review
this one," she said, when I looked up from the computer. "It
even has a Jewish angle."
Yes it did, and I trust that there has been enough commentary about this movie
that I won't be ruining it for anybody if I go so far as to say that a Mossad-like
group of perpetrators is behind the heist, not because they want the money, or
desire to hurt anyone, but because there is a historic score to settle.
About 40-50 people are taken hostage inside the bank in what was supposed to
be a perfect robbery. The hostages are made to put on the same uniforms
as the bank robbers, so it will be difficult for police to tell who is who
when ultimately they storm the place. Even the hostages wouldn't be able
to tell for sure.
Among the hostages is Brian (Amir Ali Said), an elementary school-aged boy who
has a portable video player. The leader of the bank heisters, Dalton
Russell (Clive Owen) is shocked by the game which is filled with gratuitous
street violence. Here Russell has terrorized 50 people, even beaten some
who have not cooperated, and he is lecturing to the boy about the dangers
of such graphic content. No wonder the boy shakes his head.
Denzel Washington plays Detective Keith Frazier, who is in charge of the
hostage negotiations. It doesn't take him too long to realize that these are
not your ordinary bank-robbers. Not only has their planning been
meticulous, but they seem to be anticipating his every move.
Furthermore, they don't seem to act the way other bank robbers do, nor do they
make typical demands.
Ultimately when we learn what the group's exact motives were (of course, I'm
not going to tell you), and when we see what level of precautions that
they took to insure that there were no casualties, we are almost ready
to convert the bank robbers from bad guys to good guys.
Almost.
But, in truth, we ought not to. There's still that matter of all the
people whom they terrorized—the hostages—who were humiliated, in some
cases hurt, and clearly in panic for their lives.
Even if the bank robbers succeeded in righting a historic wrong, the means
they employed were unethical and illegal. The ends do not justify the
means. And maybe that was director Spike Lee's ultimate message.