Ida Nasatir writings List of honorees Louis Rose Society Jewishsightseeing home
Ida Nasatir book review
Animal Farm by George Orwell
March 13, 1947: Book Review—Animal
Farm by George Orwell—Southwestern Jewish Press, page 6: George
Orwell's keen satirical new book, Animal Farm, does not have a Jewish
name, but its contents will appeal to all thinking people. Orwell has been
likened to Switf and Voltaire, since this book has the same double meaning, the
sharp edge, and the lucidity used so masterfully by those two literary figures. Animal
Farm is a neat little book. Once having started it, you will read it
through in one sitting. At least, you will want to. The writing is sharp and as
clear as clean glass. His central thesis is that power corrupts, and absolute
power corrupts absolutely. He illustrates this by use of animals, the latter he
turns into caricatures of Russian leaders. It appears that the animals of Manor
Farm, the cart-horses Boxer and Clover, Benjamin, the wise old donkey, the wily
pigs, the hens and geese, have long been underfed and mistreated by Mr. Jones,
their drunken owner. So, when Old Major, the prize boar, now in his twelfth year
(he is supposedly Lenin) feels the approach of death, he calls the comrades to
him, lectures them on their stupidity, fires them with the thought of rebellion
that is coming, and then, clearing his throat, begins to sing a stirring song,
"Beasts of England." Sung to the lively tune of "La
Cucaracha," it has many verses, the first two of which are: Beasts of
England, beasts of Ireland/ Beasts of every land and clime,/Hearken to my joyful
tidings/ Of the golden future time./ Soon or late the day is coming/ Tyrant Man
shall be overthrown,/ And the fruitful fields of England/ Shall be trod by
beasts alone... Soon after teaching the animals this song of liberation,
Major dies. The animals then organize under the leadership of the pigs. Two pigs
stand out—Napoleon, "not much of a talker, but with a reputation of
getting his own way (this is supposedly Stalin), and Snowball, more vivacious
and eloquent, but "not considered to have the same depth of character.
(Snowball is a caricature of Trotsky.) One weekend , Farmer Jones, drunk and
sleepy, forgets to feed the animals, and almost before they know it, the animals
have chased Jones off the farm. The pigs become the leaders. Once Jones
tries to come back, but the animals, led by Snowball, rout him at the famous
"Battle of the Cowshed." For his heroism, Snowball receives a clover
citation, "Animal Hero, First class." But shortly thereafter, Napoleon
drives Snowball off the farm, and he tells the rest of the animals, that far
from being a patriot, Snowball has been a traitor all along, plotting against
the security of animal Farm. Thereafter, everything that goes wrong on the farm,
is ascribed by Napoleon to the infamous plotting of Snowball. Slowly
Napoleon consolidates his tyrannical hold over the bewildered animals, who can
never quite understand what is happening to them. Those who wonder too much are
executed as traitors in league with Snowball. After the great purge, the singing
of "Beasts of England" is forbidden because it "expressed our
longing for a better society in days to come. But that society has now
been established. Clearly, the song has no longer any purpose." The
pigs move into Farmer Jones' house and adopt his human habits; Napoleon makes
deals with neighboring farmers, and more and more the just and decent principles
of animalism are being destroyed. The commandment, "All animals re
equal," is now changed to: "But some animals are more equal than
others," and their sacred slogan, "Four legs are good, two legs
bad!" is suddenly changed, one terrible day, as the pigs begin to walk
erect, to "Four legs good, two legs BETTER!" Sad indeed is the fate of
Boxer, the strong, kind, slow-witted horse, who is heroic in any emergency, who
gives all of his brute strength, his tears, and some of his blood to THE CAUSE.
Easy to mislead, but fundamentally decent, Boxer represents the Common Man, who
is getting more and more frightened of the century which Mr. Henry Wallace
dedicated to him. Becoming old, ill, and exhausted, Boxer, instead of
being given the promised pension of rest, and care, and good abundant food, is
sent off to be slaughtered and turned into dog food and bone meal, under the
pretext that he is being hospitalized. This allegorical fable ends with a party
thrown by the pigs for the farmers in the neighborhood. There is much eating and
drinking of strong liquor. The humans congratulate Napoleon on his control of
Animal Farm, the lower animals there, they say, do more work and receive less
food and privileges than any animals in the country. Meanwhile, the other
animals, tired, underfed, overworked, gather around the house of Mr. Jones, and
peer into the windows to watch the gala party. What they see amazes them, for
they look "from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again;
but already it is impossible to say which was which." This is a
simple story perhaps, but a story of deadly simplicity. The qualities of pathos
in the tale of the betrayal of the animals, would compel the attention of
persons who never heard of the Russian Revolution. Orwell's wit is merciless;
his pen has the razor's edge of a surgeon's knife.