Jewish Sightseeing HomePage   Jewish Sightseeing
   2003-05-09 Mothers I Knew




 

 

Memoirs

 
 

Mothers I Knew

San Diego Jewish Press-Heritage, May 9, 2003
 

 
 
 

By Donald H. Harrison

I like to tell the story of the time when I was in college and decided to take a bus trip from Los Angeles to New Orleans. When I got to Houston, I called my mother to let her know everything was all right.

     
Moms- Alice Harrison Walters, 
left, and Sydel Zeiden


We talked for a little while longer, and then I said I needed to get back to the bus. "Be careful crossing the street!" she warned.

"Mom," said I, astonished. "Iım 2,000 miles from home, and you're telling me to be careful crossing the street?"

"Wellllll," she replied, defensively.

"Well, indeed," I chuckled.

Years later, whenever my mother would get a little over-protective, I always would listen to her carefully, repeat her instructions, smile and then add: "and... I'll be careful crossing the street!"

"Oh, you!" she would reply, stomping her foot.

It became a game with us. I never could understand other sons and daughters who would get upset by similar shows of parental love.

Today, when people say "Jewish mother," I am told they are referring to mothers who try to make their adult children feel guilty for a variety of offenses.

"Mom, I canıt make it over to see you tonight."

"Don't worry, I'll sit in the dark. And who really needs heat in an apartment?"

Sometimes, they mean a mother who has very high ambitions for her children. Like the mother whose son became the first Jewish President. She pointed to him one day and told a friend: "You know, his brother is a doctor!"

I've never really understood either stereotype about Jewish mothers. I've really known two in my life— my own mother and my wifeıs mother, whom I also call "Mom."

My mother, Alice Harrison Walters, may she rest in peace, was an incredibly kind, caring woman. After my father Martin died, Mom moved down here from Los Angeles and became involved in a variety of projects, including one helping to resettle refugees from the former Soviet Union.

There was one woman, Dora, in whom mother particularly took a special interest, perhaps because her own mother's name was Dora. She remembered family stories about how the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society had helped Jews get settled in the United States. 'HIAS' was a term of reverence in Grandma Dora's household, and it brought my mother to tears thinking how she could repay the kindness by helping another Dora.

Thirty years before she died, my mother had a radical mastectomy. Recovery from the operation was not easy; I still can remember the way she winced as she would practice lifting her arm against a wall.

Mom subsequently volunteered to speak to other women who had to undergo similar surgeries for breast cancer. She would go into their rooms, introduce herself and tell them that though they may worry about disfigurement, in fact their lives would return to normal.

The women would look at Momıs beautiful trim figure and say something like, "Yeah, like how could you possibly know?" And Mom would tell them: "I know because I had the same surgery you did. I am wearing a prosthesis right now." To quell their disbelief, she sometimes would have to close the curtain and show them.

And then their questions would pour out and sometimes Mom would sit with them for hours. I met several of these women later, and they told me that, thanks to mother, they had a whole new positive attitude toward life.

Jewish mother? Alice Harrison Walters was one of them.

My wife Nancy's mother is Sydel Zeiden, a resident of Ocean Hills Country Club in Oceanside. One of 10 children, Sydel remembers how her mother, Fannie, used to cook great big dinners every day of the week, not just for Shabbat, to feed her happy, clamorous family. As they grew, the children never had to ask if they could bring friends over — at Fannie's house there
was always enough, no matter what.

Hungarian by birth, Fannie spoke enough English to know that "in-law" was not a nice phrase. To her mind, there was no such thing as an in-law. When someone married one of her sons or daughters, they became family too. She didn't differentiate between those who came by birth or those who arrived by marriage— they all were her children.

Nancy's parents, Sam and Sydel, always have treated me exactly the same way: not as a son-in-law, but as a son. Especially after my own mother died, I realized how very lucky I was to have a mother like Sydel in my life.

Jewish mothers? Fannie Fischer was one of them. And Sydel Zeiden, 80 years
young, is one of them.

My wife Nancy is an incredible mother. There is no task too demanding, no errand too time-consuming, no challenge too daunting that Nancy doesn't take on if it is for the good of our children, Sandi and David. As she raised them to adulthood, Nancy always was incredibly loyal, sometimes over-protective, exceptionally loving, slow to anger, quick to forgive.

Now that Sandi and David are grown, Nancy remains ever involved in their lives, quick to take up their cause, bear the burden, do the task.

Jewish mothers? Nancy's another one.

Our daughter Sandi and her wonderful Israeli husband, Shahar Masori, now have a 2-year-old son, Shor, who walks, talks, reasons, smiles and beguiles.

Maybe Teletubbies taught him how to do a "big hug," but Sandi has shown him how to do "an Eskimo kiss" by rubbing noses and a "butterfly kiss" by flicking his lashes on your cheek. She reads to him, teaches him, takes him on outings to share the world with him, demonstrates to him the meaning of kindness, and, yes, Sandi is a "Jewish mother" too.

Jewish mothers? The whole world should be so lucky!